Gardner: The Science of Fear

From Scienticity

Jump to: navigation, search
(New page: {{BNR-table|scienticity=4|readability=5|hermeneutics=4|charisma=4|recommendation=5}} Daniel Gardner, ''The Science of Fear : Why We Fear the Things We Shouldn’t--and Put Ourselves in Gre...)
m
 
Line 10: Line 10:
* '''The Rule of Typical Things''': we form very complex images of "typicality" to help with snap judgments, but the rule can go wrong.  We tend to go with the intuitively typical even when it flies in the face of logic and evidence; the rule is only as good as our knowledge of what is "typical" and the rule generally favors outcomes that make good stories.
* '''The Rule of Typical Things''': we form very complex images of "typicality" to help with snap judgments, but the rule can go wrong.  We tend to go with the intuitively typical even when it flies in the face of logic and evidence; the rule is only as good as our knowledge of what is "typical" and the rule generally favors outcomes that make good stories.
-
The book provides examples and discusses subtleties for the rules, then sets them against the backdrop of modern life to see how they distort our perceptions of crime, terrorism, and the use of chemicals among other risks.  Since our stone age brains can;t change, we won't abandon information technology, and the incentives for marketing fear are growing, how is fear amplified when those three basic components: the brain, the media, and people with an interest in stoking fears, are wired together in a feedback loop that creates the circuitry of fear?
+
The book provides examples and discusses subtleties for the rules, then sets them against the backdrop of modern life to see how they distort our perceptions of crime, terrorism, and the use of chemicals among other risks.  Since our stone age brains can't change, we won't abandon information technology, and the incentives for marketing fear are growing, how is fear amplified when those three basic components: the brain, the media, and people with an interest in stoking fears, are wired together in a feedback loop that creates the circuitry of fear?
The book highlights the complexities of applying hard scientific thought to certain popular attitudes such as the Precautionary Principle or the Cost No Object pursuit of safety.  Should we ban synthetic chemicals until we have a full understanding of their facts?  That attractively simple idea is a lot more complicated than it appears because banning pesticides to reduce exposure to carcinogens could potentially result in more people getting cancer if it reduces consumption of fruits and vegetables.  Or "It's worth it if even one life is saved" which we often hear.  But if a program costs $100 million and saves one life, it is almost certainly not worth it because there are many other ways $100 million could be spent that would certainly save more than one life.   
The book highlights the complexities of applying hard scientific thought to certain popular attitudes such as the Precautionary Principle or the Cost No Object pursuit of safety.  Should we ban synthetic chemicals until we have a full understanding of their facts?  That attractively simple idea is a lot more complicated than it appears because banning pesticides to reduce exposure to carcinogens could potentially result in more people getting cancer if it reduces consumption of fruits and vegetables.  Or "It's worth it if even one life is saved" which we often hear.  But if a program costs $100 million and saves one life, it is almost certainly not worth it because there are many other ways $100 million could be spent that would certainly save more than one life.   

Current revision as of 16:38, 15 June 2009

Personal tools
science time-capsules