Morgan: Poles Apart

From Scienticity

Jump to: navigation, search
m
m
 
Line 4: Line 4:
Can you trust the advice of an economist or financial adviser when it comes to the science of climate change? After all, we even suspect their advice on economic matters these days.
Can you trust the advice of an economist or financial adviser when it comes to the science of climate change? After all, we even suspect their advice on economic matters these days.
-
That might be a natural reaction to the new book “Poles Apart” by Gareth Morgan and John McCrystal. Gareth is a well-known New Zealand economist and investment portfolio manager. John McCrystal is a Wellington writer and researcher.
+
That might be a natural reaction to the new book ''Poles Apart'' by Gareth Morgan and John McCrystal. Gareth is a well-known New Zealand economist and investment portfolio manager. John McCrystal is a Wellington writer and researcher.
Surely they can’t offer anything useful on climate change? Well, strangely they can.
Surely they can’t offer anything useful on climate change? Well, strangely they can.
Line 53: Line 53:
A final niggle about the presentation of the scientific peer review process in this book. Morgan and McCrystal seem to argue against peer review – or at least that "a slavish insistence on publication in peer-reviewed journals" may "seriously skew" the data supporting the conclusion of anthropogenic global warming. They base this on the fact that most "prestigious" journals like ''Science'' and ''Nature'' may reject over 90% of submitted papers. They seem to assume that scientists always submit to "prestigious" journals and may give up before working their way down to the lower ranked journals.
A final niggle about the presentation of the scientific peer review process in this book. Morgan and McCrystal seem to argue against peer review – or at least that "a slavish insistence on publication in peer-reviewed journals" may "seriously skew" the data supporting the conclusion of anthropogenic global warming. They base this on the fact that most "prestigious" journals like ''Science'' and ''Nature'' may reject over 90% of submitted papers. They seem to assume that scientists always submit to "prestigious" journals and may give up before working their way down to the lower ranked journals.
-
However, in this case the authors must have ignored their experts as any scientist would have told them that they submit to '''appropriate''' rather than "'''prestigious'''" journals. For example, have a glance at the references listed in [http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/ar4-wg1.htm The IPCC Fourth Assessment Report] from the Working Group "The Physical Science Basis", [http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/wg1/ar4-wg1-chapter3.pdfChapter 3 "Observations Surface and Atmospheric Climate Change."[ Of about 900 references only 30 are from ''Nature'' and 41 from ''Science''. This is only about 8% of the total – I don’t think this justifies any claim of data-skewing by the publication policies of "prestigious" journals.
+
However, in this case the authors must have ignored their experts as any scientist would have told them that they submit to '''appropriate''' rather than "'''prestigious'''" journals. For example, have a glance at the references listed in [http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/ar4-wg1.htm The IPCC Fourth Assessment Report] from the Working Group "The Physical Science Basis", [http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/wg1/ar4-wg1-chapter3.pdf Chapter 3 "Observations Surface and Atmospheric Climate Change."] Of about 900 references only 30 are from ''Nature'' and 41 from ''Science''. This is only about 8% of the total – I don’t think this justifies any claim of data-skewing by the publication policies of "prestigious" journals.
For most journals a "rejection" may just be a request for improvement of language or logic, inclusion of more data or removal of superfluous data, etc. Most credible scientific papers are published after revision.
For most journals a "rejection" may just be a request for improvement of language or logic, inclusion of more data or removal of superfluous data, etc. Most credible scientific papers are published after revision.

Current revision as of 03:46, 24 September 2009

Personal tools
science time-capsules