Gilder: The Age of Entanglement
From Scienticity
(New page: {{BNR-table|scienticity=5|readability=5|hermeneutics=5|charisma=5|recommendation=5}} Louisa Gilder, ''The Age of Entanglement : When Quantum Physics was Reborn''. New York : Alfred A. Knop...) |
|||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
The title of Louisa Gilder's book is evidently meant to be literary, alluding perhaps to Auden's famous 1947 poem "The Age of Anxiety", but also to the "Age of Enlightenment", both of which lend some redolence to her subject, a quest for meaning and understanding in quantum mechanics. Also, "entanglement" can refer to several things, not least of which might refer to how any number of scientist's live have been sucked into the maelstrom of quantum mechanical hermeneutics. | The title of Louisa Gilder's book is evidently meant to be literary, alluding perhaps to Auden's famous 1947 poem "The Age of Anxiety", but also to the "Age of Enlightenment", both of which lend some redolence to her subject, a quest for meaning and understanding in quantum mechanics. Also, "entanglement" can refer to several things, not least of which might refer to how any number of scientist's live have been sucked into the maelstrom of quantum mechanical hermeneutics. | ||
| - | It also refers to a specific concept of quantum mechanics that is straightforward enough but takes some time present—in fact, it is the subject of the book. It refers to the fact that, in one incarnation, two particles can be emitted by a machine in such a way that their quantum states must form a certain combination, but which is in which state is not determined until one of the particles is observed and the wave-function of the other then "collapses" into the proper state of the other particle, regardless of how far apart they are (in particular, they could be arbitrarily further apart than would allow a "signal" between the particles to travel at the speed of light). The quantum states of the particles are "entangled". | + | It also refers to a specific concept of quantum mechanics that is straightforward enough but takes some time to present—in fact, it is the subject of the book. It refers to the fact that, in one incarnation, two particles can be emitted by a machine in such a way that their quantum states must form a certain combination, but which is in which state is not determined until one of the particles is observed and the wave-function of the other then "collapses" into the proper state of the other particle, regardless of how far apart they are (in particular, they could be arbitrarily further apart than would allow a "signal" between the particles to travel at the speed of light). The quantum states of the particles are "entangled". |
This is a notion that Einstein poo-pooed as "spooky action at a distance". Einstein, along with colleagues Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen, in 1935 published a paper in which they proposed one of Einstein's famous "thought experiments" along the lines of the two-particle experiment. Their purpose seemed to be to mock these apparent anti-commonsensical possibilities of quantum mechanics. | This is a notion that Einstein poo-pooed as "spooky action at a distance". Einstein, along with colleagues Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen, in 1935 published a paper in which they proposed one of Einstein's famous "thought experiments" along the lines of the two-particle experiment. Their purpose seemed to be to mock these apparent anti-commonsensical possibilities of quantum mechanics. | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
Fortunately, our author affords plenty of time to take in the ideas as she relates the earlier development of quantum mechanics, in order to show the origins and development of some central ideas and trace their growth, and to explain in some detail Bell's work and the work of the experimental scientists who competed to verify his predictions first. | Fortunately, our author affords plenty of time to take in the ideas as she relates the earlier development of quantum mechanics, in order to show the origins and development of some central ideas and trace their growth, and to explain in some detail Bell's work and the work of the experimental scientists who competed to verify his predictions first. | ||
| - | + | Her approach draws a great deal on nonfiction narrative—this is how she wanted to bring some life to the story of these ideas and involve many of the characters (and many of them were "characters") who created and developed the ideas. I admit to a bit of skepticism at the beginning, but I was reassured by her remarks in the introduction: | |
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
| Line 32: | Line 32: | ||
I often feel some trepidation when quantum mechanics is the subject. There are any number of authors who induce my scowl of disapproval when they seem to delight in obscuring or mystifying the odder aspects of quantum theory just for the sake of mysticism. There are enough aspects of the quantum world to induce awe and curiosity without turning it into a poster-child for new-age mysticism. | I often feel some trepidation when quantum mechanics is the subject. There are any number of authors who induce my scowl of disapproval when they seem to delight in obscuring or mystifying the odder aspects of quantum theory just for the sake of mysticism. There are enough aspects of the quantum world to induce awe and curiosity without turning it into a poster-child for new-age mysticism. | ||
| - | Ms. Gilder avoided my scowls quite adeptly. Perhaps she did not dispel all mysticisms but she comes to | + | Ms. Gilder avoided my scowls quite adeptly. Perhaps she did not dispel all mysticisms but she comes to them honestly since she is trying to recount with historical precision the intellectual groping of the scientists involved as ''they'' tried to understand. There '''are''' oddities in quantum mechanics and inscrutable ideas and results, without having to manufacture any. |
On this topic I enjoyed her excerpt from Richard Feynman giving the "Messenger Lectures" at Cornell, November 1964, on the subject "The Character of Physical Law" (later published as a book). | On this topic I enjoyed her excerpt from Richard Feynman giving the "Messenger Lectures" at Cornell, November 1964, on the subject "The Character of Physical Law" (later published as a book). | ||
