Vogel: Cat's Paws and Catapults

From Scienticity

Jump to: navigation, search
m
 
Line 10: Line 10:
Here at Ars Hermeneutica we look favorably upon any book in any subject that exhibits an analytical approach to its subject, so that it may serve as an example. ''Cat's Paws and Catapults'' has it in profusion. Barely a sentence goes by without some perceptive analysis. Here, for instance, is a comparative discussion of stiffening plates, in natural and human technology:
Here at Ars Hermeneutica we look favorably upon any book in any subject that exhibits an analytical approach to its subject, so that it may serve as an example. ''Cat's Paws and Catapults'' has it in profusion. Barely a sentence goes by without some perceptive analysis. Here, for instance, is a comparative discussion of stiffening plates, in natural and human technology:
<blockquote>
<blockquote>
-
When it comes to stiffening flat plates with a minimum of material, nothing touches insect wings. insects commonly invest only about 1 percent of body mass in their wings. Yet the wings move at several meters per second through the air, and many reverse their movement several hundred times each second. To get sufficient stiffness for this demanding application, they combine curvature, veins, and lengthwise pleats. Curvature may be an aerodynamic necessity in all but the very small insects, but it presents a special problem for beating wings: The direction of curvature that's right for a downstroke is wrong for an upstroke. Many insects have a fine solution: Their wings are built so they're curved by the force of the wind that strikes them. Since the wind on the wings reverses between upstroke and downstroke, their curvature reverses too.
+
When it comes to stiffening flat plates with a minimum of material, nothing touches insect wings. Insects commonly invest only about 1 percent of body mass in their wings. Yet the wings move at several meters per second through the air, and many reverse their movement several hundred times each second. To get sufficient stiffness for this demanding application, they combine curvature, veins, and lengthwise pleats. Curvature may be an aerodynamic necessity in all but the very small insects, but it presents a special problem for beating wings: The direction of curvature that's right for a downstroke is wrong for an upstroke. Many insects have a fine solution: Their wings are built so they're curved by the force of the wind that strikes them. Since the wind on the wings reverses between upstroke and downstroke, their curvature reverses too.
   <br><br>
   <br><br>
-
Thin, flat surfaces deflect with even small loads. The rounded shapes of our automobiles seem made for minimizing drag and wind noise and for maximizing sales appeal—the latter perhaps by tacit allusion to well-curved human bodies. In fact, the roundness of cars serves primarily to stiffen them, if more attractively than folds or ripples. Pressing a piece of metal into a curved shape is much simpler and uses less material than spot-welding a lot of stiffening strips to a plate. Sometimes we use a cruder fix; heating ducts are most often rectangular in cross section, so the6y form huge arrays of thin, flat, metal sheets. Minor changes in pressure or even temperature all too easily bow these sheets sideways and produce disconcerting noises. We minimize the problem (but don't fully fix it, at least in my house) by putting slight diagonal creases in the flat surfaces. [p. 62]
+
Thin, flat surfaces deflect with even small loads. The rounded shapes of our automobiles seem made for minimizing drag and wind noise and for maximizing sales appeal—the latter perhaps by tacit allusion to well-curved human bodies. In fact, the roundness of cars serves primarily to stiffen them, if more attractively than folds or ripples. Pressing a piece of metal into a curved shape is much simpler and uses less material than spot-welding a lot of stiffening strips to a plate. Sometimes we use a cruder fix; heating ducts are most often rectangular in cross section, so they form huge arrays of thin, flat, metal sheets. Minor changes in pressure or even temperature all too easily bow these sheets sideways and produce disconcerting noises. We minimize the problem (but don't fully fix it, at least in my house) by putting slight diagonal creases in the flat surfaces. [p. 62]
</blockquote>
</blockquote>
The implication is that Vogel writes with a great economy of words and expression, with a consequent increase in the density of ideas in the text. There's a lot "why?", and a lot of answers in this book. But the reader's response is obvious: read a bit more slowly and savor the ideas.
The implication is that Vogel writes with a great economy of words and expression, with a consequent increase in the density of ideas in the text. There's a lot "why?", and a lot of answers in this book. But the reader's response is obvious: read a bit more slowly and savor the ideas.
Line 32: Line 32:
Endlessly fascinating observations, blending biology and engineering, seem to litter the narrative, a narrative that nevertheless is quite coherent and organized. There are any number of curiosities to pick up and examine, and each one has a little conceptual lesson on offer.
Endlessly fascinating observations, blending biology and engineering, seem to litter the narrative, a narrative that nevertheless is quite coherent and organized. There are any number of curiosities to pick up and examine, and each one has a little conceptual lesson on offer.
<blockquote>
<blockquote>
-
A person could hang from a patch of standard Velcro less than five inches in diameter, but such a patch can be peeled loose with one hand. To hold strongly but release with ease, Velcro (like adhesive tape) takes clever advantage of what's called a dimensional reduction. It holds against a force extending over a broad are, while it peels in response to a force concentrated along a line; it attaches in two dimensions but releases in one. A pair of scissors or a zipper does the same thing, except that instead of reducing an area to a line, it reduces a one-dimensional line to a nondimensional point. To bring matters full circle, dimensional reduction is important in nature as well. As they get food, lots of animals peel and tear—that is, they reduce an area to a line or a line to a point; that's how a cat uses its claws and a caterpillar cuts through a leaf. Conversely, some limpets have broad skirts that make them hard to peel off rocks. Also, grasses have lengthwise veins that help them resist crosswise tearing. [pp. 269—270]
+
A person could hang from a patch of standard Velcro less than five inches in diameter, but such a patch can be peeled loose with one hand. To hold strongly but release with ease, Velcro (like adhesive tape) takes clever advantage of what's called a dimensional reduction. It holds against a force extending over a broad area, while it peels in response to a force concentrated along a line; it attaches in two dimensions but releases in one. A pair of scissors or a zipper does the same thing, except that instead of reducing an area to a line, it reduces a one-dimensional line to a nondimensional point. To bring matters full circle, dimensional reduction is important in nature as well. As they get food, lots of animals peel and tear—that is, they reduce an area to a line or a line to a point; that's how a cat uses its claws and a caterpillar cuts through a leaf. Conversely, some limpets have broad skirts that make them hard to peel off rocks. Also, grasses have lengthwise veins that help them resist crosswise tearing. [pp. 269—270]
</blockquote>
</blockquote>
Vogel's understanding, which he tries very hard to share so we can appreciate its sweep, is profound and not just limited to observations of details, but comprehension of the more abstract as well. And, he has drawn lines, as he explains in his conclusion:
Vogel's understanding, which he tries very hard to share so we can appreciate its sweep, is profound and not just limited to observations of details, but comprehension of the more abstract as well. And, he has drawn lines, as he explains in his conclusion:
<blockquote>
<blockquote>
-
Similarity of product need not imply similarity of process. I'm persuaded that comparing the products of the two technologies [nature's and humankind's] lends breadth to our thinking and gives insights not otherwise evident. About processes I'm more equivocal. Natural selection is a most peculiar process, and its limitation are inadequately appreciated. One often encounters analogies between the processes by which human technology changes and evolution by natural selection. I think these badly need the scrutiny of a biologist. To start with, a clear distinction ought to be made between mechanism and history—the distinction we biologists make between natural selection and natural history. The more basic problem is that an analogy doesn't explain. one judges an analogy not by whether it's true, trivial, or untrue but by whether it's useful, nonuseful, or misleading. [p. 298]
+
Similarity of product need not imply similarity of process. I'm persuaded that comparing the products of the two technologies [nature's and humankind's] lends breadth to our thinking and gives insights not otherwise evident. About processes I'm more equivocal. Natural selection is a most peculiar process, and its limitation are inadequately appreciated. One often encounters analogies between the processes by which human technology changes and evolution by natural selection. I think these badly need the scrutiny of a biologist. To start with, a clear distinction ought to be made between mechanism and history—the distinction we biologists make between natural selection and natural history. The more basic problem is that an analogy doesn't explain. One judges an analogy not by whether it's true, trivial, or untrue but by whether it's useful, nonuseful, or misleading. [p. 298]
</blockquote>
</blockquote>
I had great, great fun reading this book, and I learned a great deal from reading it. I can recommend it to most general readers who find the topic at all appealing.  
I had great, great fun reading this book, and I learned a great deal from reading it. I can recommend it to most general readers who find the topic at all appealing.  
Line 42: Line 42:
{{Notesby|JNS}}
{{Notesby|JNS}}
-
[[Category: Book Notes]]
+
[[Category: Book Notes]][[Category: Top-Rated Books]]
 +
[[Category: JNS]]

Current revision as of 01:40, 15 April 2009

Personal tools
science time-capsules