Ball: Critical Mass
From Scienticity
m |
|||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
| - | Since condensed-matter physics in general, and critical phenomena in particular, was once my area of expertise. I will venture to correct one small error that Ball makes in describing fluctuations in fluids near the critical point. | + | Since condensed-matter physics in general, and critical phenomena in particular, was once my area of expertise. I will venture to correct one small error that Ball makes in describing fluctuations in fluids near the critical point. He writes |
| + | <blockquote> | ||
| + | One experimental peculiarity that the theory [a late 19th century by physicist van der Waals) did embrace was the extraordinary sensitivity of the critical point. A system near its critical state becomes extremely responsive to disturbances. If you squeeze a substance, it shrinks in volume. The resistance it offers to the is compression is a measure of its so-called <i>compressibility</i> A rubber ball is more compressible than a steel, ball, and a gas is typically much more compressible than a liquid--one can squeeze it more easily. At the critical point of a liquid and gas, the fluid becomes absurdly compressible--in fact, more or less infinitely so. In principle, the gentlest squeeze is sufficient to collapse a critical fluid into invisibility. This sounds absurd, and experimentally one can never observe such extreme behavior, because maintaining a substance exactly at its critical point is too difficult--the critical state is too unstable. but one can see the compressibility start to increase very rapidly as the critical point is approached. [p. 228] | ||
| + | </blockquote> | ||
| + | This capture the essence, but the fluctuations (in density, which correspond to fluctuations in local temperature) are unstable only ''below'' the critical temperature. Above the critical temperature the fluctuations can grow to nearly macroscopic sizes but they remain stable, although it does take quite a bit of work to contrive getting a system that close to the critical point and keeping it there. | ||
Ball writes with what I've come to expect as his accustomed clarity on some pretty challenging concepts; he gets the important meanings across through good exposition, without the use of silly and imprecise analogies. On nearly every page I found stimulating ideas and informative, exciting writing. This is another book that requires some investment in time to get through it, but the reader is well rewarded for the effort. | Ball writes with what I've come to expect as his accustomed clarity on some pretty challenging concepts; he gets the important meanings across through good exposition, without the use of silly and imprecise analogies. On nearly every page I found stimulating ideas and informative, exciting writing. This is another book that requires some investment in time to get through it, but the reader is well rewarded for the effort. | ||
| Line 36: | Line 40: | ||
{{Notesby|JNS}} | {{Notesby|JNS}} | ||
| - | [[Category: Book Notes]] | + | [[Category: Book Notes]][[Category: Top-Rated Books]][[Category: JNS]] |
