Legislating the Value of Pi
From Scienticity
JNShaumeyer (Talk | contribs) |
JNShaumeyer (Talk | contribs) m (Making the italicizing of "pi" more consistent.) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The greek letter ''pi'' is the mathematical symbol used to represent the number that is the ratio of the circumference of a circle to the length of the circle's diameter. The number is known to be an irrational number{{ref|irrational}}, approximated by the fraction "22/7", or by the decimal "3.1415926536". | The greek letter ''pi'' is the mathematical symbol used to represent the number that is the ratio of the circumference of a circle to the length of the circle's diameter. The number is known to be an irrational number{{ref|irrational}}, approximated by the fraction "22/7", or by the decimal "3.1415926536". | ||
| - | Pi, no doubt because of its fundamental place in geometry and the irritation of its irrationality, has inspired a number of mystics and charlatans throughout history, particularly through vain efforts to "square the circle". Proof in 1882 that the task was impossible{{ref|square}} apparently did as little to quench interest in the ancient conundrum as thermodynamics did to halt the search for perpetual-motion machines. | + | ''Pi'', no doubt because of its fundamental place in geometry and the irritation of its irrationality, has inspired a number of mystics and charlatans throughout history, particularly through vain efforts to "square the circle". Proof in 1882 that the task was impossible{{ref|square}} apparently did as little to quench interest in the ancient conundrum as thermodynamics did to halt the search for perpetual-motion machines. |
== Indiana House Bill #246 == | == Indiana House Bill #246 == | ||
The most famous -- and only known – case of a state legislature in the US attempting to create by law a new value for ''pi'' was that of Indiana in 1897; it has become legendary, and the basis of myth and hoax. Although it has come to represent the occasional ignorance of innumerate legislators, it was not so obviously a bad idea at the time. | The most famous -- and only known – case of a state legislature in the US attempting to create by law a new value for ''pi'' was that of Indiana in 1897; it has become legendary, and the basis of myth and hoax. Although it has come to represent the occasional ignorance of innumerate legislators, it was not so obviously a bad idea at the time. | ||
| - | The bill was introduced to the house by legislator Mr. Record, but it was reported that "Mr. Record knows nothing of the bill with the exception that he introduced it by request of Dr. Edwin Goodwin of Posey County, who is the author of the demonstration."{{ref|thebill}} The bill began in the Committee on Canals (aka the Committee on Swamp Lands), whose chairman tried to send it to the Committee on Education. | + | The bill was introduced to the house by legislator Mr. Record, but it was reported that "Mr. Record knows nothing of the bill with the exception that he introduced it by request of Dr. Edwin Goodwin of Posey County, who is the author of the demonstration."{{ref|thebill}} The bill began in the Committee on Canals (aka the Committee on Swamp Lands), whose chairman tried unsuccessfully to send it to the Committee on Education. |
| - | Redefining the value of pi seems not to have been its | + | Redefining the value of ''pi'' seems not to have been its principal goal, but a side effect. In fact, the bill seems to have offered four different, new values for ''pi''. Rather, the bill was aimed at benefiting its author, who claimed to have patented a new method for "squaring the circle", which he proposed to let the state of Indiana use free of charge if they would pass his bill! Its opening statement is clear: |
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
| Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
Regardless of its short life and eventual failure to become law, Indiana House Bill #246 has left a legacy. | Regardless of its short life and eventual failure to become law, Indiana House Bill #246 has left a legacy. | ||
| - | * "Like trying to legislate the value of pi" has become a catch phrase used to highlight the patent uselessness of trying to determine mathematical or scientific fact by non-scientific means.{{ref|phrase}} | + | * "Like trying to legislate the value of ''pi''" has become a catch phrase used to highlight the patent uselessness of trying to determine mathematical or scientific fact by non-scientific means.{{ref|phrase}} |
| - | * It has become an icon, representing misguided attempts on the part of legislative bodies to legislate that which cannot be legislated; moves to legislate the value of pi have, at times, erroneously been ascribed to the state legislatures of Oklahoma, Kansas, Tennessee, Kentucky, and Alabama. | + | * It has become an icon, representing misguided attempts on the part of legislative bodies to legislate that which cannot be legislated; moves to legislate the value of ''pi'' have, at times, erroneously been ascribed to the state legislatures of Oklahoma, Kansas, Tennessee, Kentucky, and Alabama. |
| - | * In these times of more visible anti-scientific attitudes, the vague memory of the incident in Indiana lent credibility to an April Fool's Day hoax from 1998 claiming that the Alabama state legislature had, indeed, just passed legislation changing the value of pi to equal "3", bringing it into line with the value given in the ''Bible''.{{ref|alabama}} The jape has been remarkably persistent{{ref|hoax}} and popular.{{ref|museum}} | + | * In these times of more visible anti-scientific attitudes, the vague memory of the incident in Indiana lent credibility to an April Fool's Day hoax from 1998 claiming that the Alabama state legislature had, indeed, just passed legislation changing the value of ''pi'' to equal "3", bringing it into line with the value given in the ''Bible''.{{ref|alabama}} The jape has been remarkably persistent{{ref|hoax}} and popular.{{ref|museum}} |
== Notes == | == Notes == | ||
| - | #{{note|irrational}} "Irrational" means that the number cannot be written as a ratio of two integer numbers, as in "1/2" or "7/8". This implies that when irrational numbers are written as decimal numbers, the digits to the right of the decimal point never repeat and never end. In fact, | + | #{{note|irrational}} "Irrational" means that the number cannot be written as a ratio of two integer numbers, as in "1/2" or "7/8". This implies that when irrational numbers are written as decimal numbers, the digits to the right of the decimal point never repeat and never end. In fact, ''pi'' is also a transcendental number, meaning that it is not the root of any algebraic equation with rational coefficients; one implication is that age-old efforts to "square the circle" are guaranteed fruitless endeavors. |
#{{note|square}}See, e.g., [http://www.cut-the-knot.org/impossible/sq_circle.shtml "Squaring the Circle"]. | #{{note|square}}See, e.g., [http://www.cut-the-knot.org/impossible/sq_circle.shtml "Squaring the Circle"]. | ||
#{{note|thebill}}The entire text of the bill, along with contemporary commentary, is in the entry [http://faqs.jmas.co.jp/FAQs/sci-math-faq/indianabill "sci.math FAQ: Indiana Bill sets value of Pi to 3"] by Alex Lopez-Ortiz, 17 Feb 2000, which provides most of the historical details given above. | #{{note|thebill}}The entire text of the bill, along with contemporary commentary, is in the entry [http://faqs.jmas.co.jp/FAQs/sci-math-faq/indianabill "sci.math FAQ: Indiana Bill sets value of Pi to 3"] by Alex Lopez-Ortiz, 17 Feb 2000, which provides most of the historical details given above. | ||
| Line 50: | Line 50: | ||
#{{note|museum}}The Museum of Hoaxes lists it as #7 on their [http://www.museumofhoaxes.com/hoax/aprilfool/ "Top 100 April Fool's Day Hoaxes of All Time"], c. 2003. | #{{note|museum}}The Museum of Hoaxes lists it as #7 on their [http://www.museumofhoaxes.com/hoax/aprilfool/ "Top 100 April Fool's Day Hoaxes of All Time"], c. 2003. | ||
== Sources == | == Sources == | ||
| - | * The entry for [http://www.math.com/tables/constants/pi.htm "Pi"] at ''math.com'', has interesting facts, the first 1000 digits of pi, and useful links. | + | * The entry for [http://www.math.com/tables/constants/pi.htm "Pi"] at ''math.com'', has interesting facts, the first 1000 digits of ''pi'', and useful links. |
| - | * Cecil Adams, [http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a3_341.html "Did a state legislature once pass a law saying pi equals 3?"], ''The Straight Dope'', c. 1998. | + | * Cecil Adams, [http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a3_341.html "Did a state legislature once pass a law saying ''pi'' equals 3?"], ''The Straight Dope'', c. 1998. |
| - | * John Roach, [http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/03/0331_030401_aprilfool.html April Fools' Special: History's Hoaxes"], ''National Geographic'', 1 April 2003, discussed several famous hoaxes, including the one discussed above about the Alabama legislature changing the value of pi. | + | * John Roach, [http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/03/0331_030401_aprilfool.html "April Fools' Special: History's Hoaxes"], ''National Geographic'', 1 April 2003, discussed several famous hoaxes, including the one discussed above about the Alabama legislature changing the value of ''pi''. |
| - | [[Category: | + | [[Category:From the 19th Century]] |
