Evolution and the Vatican
From Scienticity
JNShaumeyer (Talk | contribs) |
JNShaumeyer (Talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
This presentation makes is clearer that the original statement is not so much hostile to science as it is trying to be clear about the boundaries between science and theology; the assertions that reason and faith cannot be in conflict will be echoed in later statements by other pontiffs. | This presentation makes is clearer that the original statement is not so much hostile to science as it is trying to be clear about the boundaries between science and theology; the assertions that reason and faith cannot be in conflict will be echoed in later statements by other pontiffs. | ||
| - | It is true that the First Vatican Council followed the publication of | + | It is true that the First Vatican Council followed the publication of ain direct response to it rather than to the mood of the times, which saw scientific advances on many fronts. Indeed, Pius IX, who presided over the dissolution of the Papal States during his pontificate, probably had bigger things on his mind.{{ref|pix01}} |
== Leo XIII == | == Leo XIII == | ||
| Line 46: | Line 46: | ||
== Pius XII == | == Pius XII == | ||
| - | Pius XII was Pope from 1939 to 1958. He was the first to acknowledge the existence of evolutionary biology -- it has been suggested that the Church had learned from its persecution of Galileo not to rush into judgement on scientific matters. His 1950 encyclical ''Humani Generis''{{ref|piusxii}} is concerned with errors of thought that "threaten to undermine Catholic doctrine", which sounds an ominous tone for the Church's first pronouncement on Evolution. However, while he rails against modern-day thinkers who would reject centuries-old doctrine as "out of date", he avoids invective against evolutionary biology. | + | Pius XII was Pope from 1939 to 1958. He was the first to acknowledge the existence of evolutionary biology -- it has been suggested that the Church had learned from its persecution of Galileo not to rush into judgement on scientific matters. His 1950 encyclical ''Humani Generis''{{ref|piusxii}} is concerned with errors of thought that "threaten to undermine Catholic doctrine", which sounds an ominous tone for the Church's first pronouncement on Evolution. However, while he rails against modern-day thinkers who would reject centuries-old doctrine as "out of date", he noticably avoids invective against evolutionary biology. |
| - | Pius XII was a religious conservative who clearly wasn't happy with the idea of evolution, | + | Pius XII was a religious conservative who clearly wasn't happy with the idea of evolution, evidently hoping, as one commentator put it{{ref|piusxii02}}, "that evolution will prove to be a passing scientific fad". So, in paragraph 30 of ''Humani Generis'', he cautions against those "fads" in thought, at the same time that he reaffirms Leo XIII's dictum that "truth cannot contradict truth": |
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
Whatever new truth the sincere human mind is able to find, certainly cannot be opposed to truth already acquired, since God, the Highest Truth, has created and guides the human intellect, not that it may daily oppose new truths to rightly established ones, but rather that, having eliminated errors which may have crept in, it may build truth upon truth in the same order and structure that exist in reality, the source of truth. Let no Christian, therefore, whether philosopher or theologian, embrace eagerly and lightly whatever novelty happens to be thought up from day to day, but rather let him weigh it with painstaking care and a balanced judgment, lest he lose or corrupt the truth he already has, with grave danger and damage to his faith. | Whatever new truth the sincere human mind is able to find, certainly cannot be opposed to truth already acquired, since God, the Highest Truth, has created and guides the human intellect, not that it may daily oppose new truths to rightly established ones, but rather that, having eliminated errors which may have crept in, it may build truth upon truth in the same order and structure that exist in reality, the source of truth. Let no Christian, therefore, whether philosopher or theologian, embrace eagerly and lightly whatever novelty happens to be thought up from day to day, but rather let him weigh it with painstaking care and a balanced judgment, lest he lose or corrupt the truth he already has, with grave danger and damage to his faith. | ||
| Line 60: | Line 60: | ||
== John Paul II == | == John Paul II == | ||
| - | + | Nearly 50 years passed between the time that Pius XII cautiously recognized that evolutionary biology need not be in conflict with church doctrine and the time when John Paul II famously made his stronger, more positive statement about evolution. Pius Xii's hope that evolution would turn out to be a scientific fad was most assuredly not realized. | |
| + | In 1996, Pope John Paul II made a speech to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences, known as "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"{{ref|jp01}}. The title acknowledges the contribution of Leo XIII and the history of this metaphysical statement. It contains John Paul II's most direct remarks about the position of the Roman Catholic Church towards modern evolutionary biology. | ||
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
| - | Today, almost half a century after the publication of the encyclical [<em>Humani Generis</em> | + | Today, almost half a century after the publication of the encyclical [<em>Humani Generis</em>], new knowledge has led to the recognition of the theory of evolution as more than a hypothesis. [...] It is indeed remarkable that this theory has been progressively accepted by researchers, following a series of discoveries in various fields of knowledge. The convergence, neither sought nor fabricated, of the results of work that was conducted independently is in itself a significant argument in favor of this theory. And if, at first sight, there are apparent contradictions, in what direction do we look for their solution? We know, in fact, that truth cannot contradict truth (cf. Leo XIII, encyclical <em>Providentissimus Deus</em>). |
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
| + | At the time there was considerable consternation among American anti-evolutionists, who made hopeful assertions that perhpas the original French had been badly translated into "more than a hypothesis". However, the Vatican quickly confirmed that John Paul II had meant exactly what he had said. | ||
| - | In a 1987 letter to the Director of the Vatican Observatory{{ref|jp02}} on the occasion of a "study week" held at Castelgandolfo in Rome to mark the 300th anniversary of the publication of Newton's ''Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica'', John Paul II made broader statements about the cross-fertilization possible between science and theology | + | In a 1987 letter to the Director of the Vatican Observatory{{ref|jp02}} on the occasion of a "study week" held at Castelgandolfo in Rome to mark the 300th anniversary of the publication of Newton's ''Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica'', John Paul II made broader statements about the cross-fertilization possible between science and theology. |
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
Religion is not founded on science nor is science an extension of religion. Each should possess its own principles, its pattern of procedures, its diversities of interpretation and its own conclusions. Christianity possesses the source of its justification within itself and does not expect science to constitute its primary apologetic. Science must bear witness to its own worth. While each can and should support the other as distinct dimensions of a common human culture, neither ought to assume that it forms a necessary premise for the other. The unprecedented opportunity we have today is for a common interactive relationship in which each discipline retains its integrity and yet is radically open to the discoveries and insights of the other. | Religion is not founded on science nor is science an extension of religion. Each should possess its own principles, its pattern of procedures, its diversities of interpretation and its own conclusions. Christianity possesses the source of its justification within itself and does not expect science to constitute its primary apologetic. Science must bear witness to its own worth. While each can and should support the other as distinct dimensions of a common human culture, neither ought to assume that it forms a necessary premise for the other. The unprecedented opportunity we have today is for a common interactive relationship in which each discipline retains its integrity and yet is radically open to the discoveries and insights of the other. | ||
| Line 75: | Line 77: | ||
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
| - | == Benedict | + | == Benedict XVI == |
| + | So far, the papacy of Benedict XVI is too young to have seen any official statements directly addressing the the relationship of the Roman Catholic Church towards science. Some commentators felt that an op-ed piece by Austrian Cardinal Schoenborn in the ''New York Times'', which appeared in July 2005 shortly after Benedict's election, may have been meant to indicate a more hard-line position of Benedict XVI towards evolution, but this interpretation quickly dissipated. (See our article [[The Cardinal, The Astronomer, and Darwin]]. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Although there is no direct statemtent yet by Benedict XVI, we do have this 2002 statement from the Internation Theological Commission, held in Rome from 2000-2002, of which Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger was the president.{{ref|benedict01}} | ||
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
| - | |||
| - | |||
63. According to the widely accepted scientific account, the universe erupted 15 billion years ago in an explosion called the “Big Bang” and has been expanding and cooling ever since. Later there gradually emerged the conditions necessary for the formation of atoms, still later the condensation of galaxies and stars, and about 10 billion years later the formation of planets. In our own solar system and on earth (formed about 4.5 billion years ago), the conditions have been favorable to the emergence of life. While there is little consensus among scientists about how the origin of this first microscopic life is to be explained, there is general agreement among them that the first organism dwelt on this planet about 3.5-4 billion years ago. Since it has been demonstrated that all living organisms on earth are genetically related, it is virtually certain that all living organisms have descended from this first organism. Converging evidence from many studies in the physical and biological sciences furnishes mounting support for some theory of evolution to account for the development and diversification of life on earth, while controversy continues over the pace and mechanisms of evolution. While the story of human origins is complex and subject to revision, physical anthropology and molecular biology combine to make a convincing case for the origin of the human species in Africa about 150,000 years ago in a humanoid population of common genetic lineage. However it is to be explained, the decisive factor in human origins was a continually increasing brain size, culminating in that of ''homo sapiens''. With the development of the human brain, the nature and rate of evolution were permanently altered: with the introduction of the uniquely human factors of consciousness, intentionality, freedom and creativity, biological evolution was recast as social and cultural evolution. | 63. According to the widely accepted scientific account, the universe erupted 15 billion years ago in an explosion called the “Big Bang” and has been expanding and cooling ever since. Later there gradually emerged the conditions necessary for the formation of atoms, still later the condensation of galaxies and stars, and about 10 billion years later the formation of planets. In our own solar system and on earth (formed about 4.5 billion years ago), the conditions have been favorable to the emergence of life. While there is little consensus among scientists about how the origin of this first microscopic life is to be explained, there is general agreement among them that the first organism dwelt on this planet about 3.5-4 billion years ago. Since it has been demonstrated that all living organisms on earth are genetically related, it is virtually certain that all living organisms have descended from this first organism. Converging evidence from many studies in the physical and biological sciences furnishes mounting support for some theory of evolution to account for the development and diversification of life on earth, while controversy continues over the pace and mechanisms of evolution. While the story of human origins is complex and subject to revision, physical anthropology and molecular biology combine to make a convincing case for the origin of the human species in Africa about 150,000 years ago in a humanoid population of common genetic lineage. However it is to be explained, the decisive factor in human origins was a continually increasing brain size, culminating in that of ''homo sapiens''. With the development of the human brain, the nature and rate of evolution were permanently altered: with the introduction of the uniquely human factors of consciousness, intentionality, freedom and creativity, biological evolution was recast as social and cultural evolution. | ||
| + | <br><br> | ||
| + | 64. Pope John Paul II stated some years ago that "new knowledge leads to the recognition of the theory of evolution as more than a hypothesis. It is indeed remarkable that this theory has been progressively accepted by researchers following a series of discoveries in various fields of knowledge"("Message to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on Evolution" 1996). In continuity with previous twentieth century papal teaching on evolution (especially Pope Pius XII’s encyclical ''Humani Generis''), the Holy Father’s message acknowledges that there are “several theories of evolution” that are "materialist, reductionist and spiritualist" and thus incompatible with the Catholic faith. It follows that the message of Pope John Paul II cannot be read as a blanket approbation of all theories of evolution, including those of a neo-Darwinian provenance which explicitly deny to divine providence any truly causal role in the development of life in the universe. [...] | ||
| + | <br><br> | ||
| + | 69. The current scientific debate about the mechanisms at work in evolution requires theological comment insofar as it sometimes implies a misunderstanding of the nature of divine causality. Many neo-Darwinian scientists, as well as some of their critics, have concluded that, if evolution is a radically contingent materialistic process driven by natural selection and random genetic variation, then there can be no place in it for divine providential causality. A growing body of scientific critics of neo-Darwinism point to evidence of design (e.g., biological structures that exhibit specified complexity) that, in their view, cannot be explained in terms of a purely cos important to note that, according to the Catholic understanding of divine causality, true contingency in the created order is not incompatible with a purposeful divine providence. | ||
| + | </blockquote> | ||
| - | + | Yet to be seen is whether this interpretation of previous papal positions will remain central to the new Pope's teachings on evolution. | |
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
== Conclusion == | == Conclusion == | ||
| - | |||
| - | |||
| - | |||
== Notes == | == Notes == | ||
| Line 114: | Line 109: | ||
#{{note|jp01}}John Paul II, [http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_jp02tc.htm "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"], address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on 22 October 1996. | #{{note|jp01}}John Paul II, [http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_jp02tc.htm "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"], address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on 22 October 1996. | ||
#{{note|jp02}}John Paul II, [http://www.its.caltech.edu/~nmcenter/sci-cp/sci-coyne.html "Our knowledge of God and nature: physics, philosophy and theology"], Letter "To the Reverend George V. Coyne, S.J., Director of the Vatican Observatory", date 1 June 1988, originally published in ''L'Osservatore Romano (Weekly edition in English)'', '''xxi''':46 (1064), 14 November 1988. | #{{note|jp02}}John Paul II, [http://www.its.caltech.edu/~nmcenter/sci-cp/sci-coyne.html "Our knowledge of God and nature: physics, philosophy and theology"], Letter "To the Reverend George V. Coyne, S.J., Director of the Vatican Observatory", date 1 June 1988, originally published in ''L'Osservatore Romano (Weekly edition in English)'', '''xxi''':46 (1064), 14 November 1988. | ||
| + | #{{note|benedict01}}[http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20040723_communion-stewardship_en.html Communion and Stewardship: Human Persons Created in the Image of God"], c. 2002: "The theme of 'man created in the image of God' was submitted for study to the International Theological Commission. [...] As the text developed, it was discussed at numerous meetings of the subcommission and several plenary sessions of the International Theological Commission held at Rome during the period 2000-2002. The present text was approved in forma specifica, by the written ballots of the International Theological Commission. It was then submitted to Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, the President of the Commission, who has give his permission for its publication." | ||
== Sources == | == Sources == | ||
*George V. Coyne, [http://clavius.as.arizona.edu/vo/R1024/AReports/FDirec00.html "From the Director"], ''The Vatican Observatory: 2000 Annual Report'', 10 April 2001. | *George V. Coyne, [http://clavius.as.arizona.edu/vo/R1024/AReports/FDirec00.html "From the Director"], ''The Vatican Observatory: 2000 Annual Report'', 10 April 2001. | ||
| + | *Stephen Jay Gould, [http://www.stephenjaygould.org/library/gould_noma.html "Nonoverlapping Magisteria"], ''The Unofficial Stephen Jay Gould Archive''; originally printed in ''Natural History'' '''106''', March 1997, pp. 16-22 | ||
*James Hannam, [http://www.bede.org.uk/historyessays.htm#index "Looking it up in the Index"], 2000. | *James Hannam, [http://www.bede.org.uk/historyessays.htm#index "Looking it up in the Index"], 2000. | ||
*Keelin McDonell, [http://slate.msn.com/id/2122506/ "What Catholics Think of Evolution: They don't not believe in it."], ''Slate'', 12 July 2005. | *Keelin McDonell, [http://slate.msn.com/id/2122506/ "What Catholics Think of Evolution: They don't not believe in it."], ''Slate'', 12 July 2005. | ||
