Evolution and the Vatican

From Scienticity

Jump to: navigation, search
Line 23: Line 23:
11. Hence, so far is the Church from hindering the development of human arts and studies, that in fact she assists and promotes them in many ways. For she is neither ignorant nor contemptuous of the advantages which derive from this source for human life, rather she acknowledges that those things flow from God, the lord of sciences, and, if they are properly used, lead to God by the help of his grace.
11. Hence, so far is the Church from hindering the development of human arts and studies, that in fact she assists and promotes them in many ways. For she is neither ignorant nor contemptuous of the advantages which derive from this source for human life, rather she acknowledges that those things flow from God, the lord of sciences, and, if they are properly used, lead to God by the help of his grace.
</blockquote>
</blockquote>
-
This presentation makes is clearer that the statement is not so much hostile to science as it is trying to be clear about the boundaries between science and theology; the assertions that reason and faith cannot be in conflict will be echoed in later statements by other pontiffs.
+
This presentation makes is clearer that the original statement is not so much hostile to science as it is trying to be clear about the boundaries between science and theology; the assertions that reason and faith cannot be in conflict will be echoed in later statements by other pontiffs.
-
 
+
-
It is true that the First Vatican Council followed the publication of ''The Origin of Species'' by 10 years, but there's really nothing to suggest that the decrees of the council were in direct response to it rather than to the mood of the times, which saw scientific advances on many fronts. Indeed, Pius IX, who saw the end of the Papal States during his pontificate, probably had bigger things on his mind.{{ref|pix01}}
+
-
 
+
 +
It is true that the First Vatican Council followed the publication of ''The Origin of Species'' by 10 years, but nothing suggests that the decrees of the council were in direct response to it rather than to the mood of the times, which saw scientific advances on many fronts. Indeed, Pius IX, who presided over the dissolution of the Papal States during his pontificate, probably had bigger things on his mind.{{ref|pix01}}
== Leo XIII ==
== Leo XIII ==
-
John Paul II, in stating that "truth cannot contradict truth", referred to the encyclical [http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/leo_xiii/encyclicals/documents/hf_l-xiii_enc_18111893_providentissimus-deus_en.html ''Providentissimus Deus''], "given at St. Peter's, at Rome, the 18th day of November, 1893, the eighteenth year of Our Pontificate: Leo XII." That encylical concerned the the study of the Scriptures and did not directly discuss science, scientific truth, and its relationship to theology.  
+
The notion that faith and reason can never truly be in conflict was expressed more directly, and more memorably, in the encyclical ''Providentissimus Deus'',{{ref|leo01}} written by Pius' successor, Leo XIII, in 1893. The encylical concerned the the study of the Scriptures and did not directly discuss science, scientific truth, and its relationship to theology. In the concluding paragraphs he wrote:
-
 
+
-
However,
+
<blockquote>
<blockquote>
23. In order that all these endeavours and exertions [related to the study of the Scriptures, which is the topic of the encyclical] may really prove advantageous to the cause of the Bible, let scholars keep steadfastly to the principles which We have in this Letter laid down. Let them loyally hold that God, the Creator and Ruler of all things, is also the Author of the Scriptures - and that therefore nothing can be proved either by physical science or archaeology which can really contradict the Scriptures. If, then, apparent contradiction be met with, every effort should be made to remove it. Judicious theologians and commentators should be consulted as to what is the true or most probable meaning of the passage in discussion, and the hostile arguments should be carefully weighed. Even if the difficulty is after all not cleared up and the discrepancy seems to remain, the contest must not be abandoned; truth cannot contradict truth, and we may be sure that some mistake has been made either in the interpretation of the sacred words, or in the polemical discussion itself; and if no such mistake can be detected, we must then suspend judgment for the time being.  
23. In order that all these endeavours and exertions [related to the study of the Scriptures, which is the topic of the encyclical] may really prove advantageous to the cause of the Bible, let scholars keep steadfastly to the principles which We have in this Letter laid down. Let them loyally hold that God, the Creator and Ruler of all things, is also the Author of the Scriptures - and that therefore nothing can be proved either by physical science or archaeology which can really contradict the Scriptures. If, then, apparent contradiction be met with, every effort should be made to remove it. Judicious theologians and commentators should be consulted as to what is the true or most probable meaning of the passage in discussion, and the hostile arguments should be carefully weighed. Even if the difficulty is after all not cleared up and the discrepancy seems to remain, the contest must not be abandoned; truth cannot contradict truth, and we may be sure that some mistake has been made either in the interpretation of the sacred words, or in the polemical discussion itself; and if no such mistake can be detected, we must then suspend judgment for the time being.  
</blockquote>
</blockquote>
 +
 +
Again, there is no display of hostility towards the scientific endeavor, nor any particular mention of Darwin. Rather, there is the restatement of the of doctrine from Pius IX: the metaphysical presumption that the results of rational investigation and the results of theological investigation can never truly be in conflict -- that "truth cannot contradict truth", and that any appearance to the contrary is therefore the result of incomplete understanding.
== Pius X ==
== Pius X ==
-
In his 1907 encyclical "On the Doctrine of the Modernists"{{ref|piusx01}}, Pius X wrote a stern -- and lengthy -- denunciation of "modernists" whose attitudes and teachings he found to be a serious threat to the Church. In that context, his remarks in passing on science seem far from hostile; in fact, by today's standards, they are next to indifferent.
+
In his 1907 encyclical "On the Doctrine of the Modernists"{{ref|piusx01}}, Pius X wrote a stern -- and lengthy -- denunciation of "modernists" whose attitudes and teachings he found to be a serious threat to the Church. In that context, his remarks in passing on science seem far less hostile than they seem in this excerpt; in fact, by today's standards, they border on the indifferent.
<blockquote>
<blockquote>
47. With regard to secular studies, let it suffice to recall here what our predecessor [Leo XIII] has admirably said: "Apply yourselves energetically to the study of natural sciences: in which department the things that have been so brilliantly discovered, and so usefully applied, to the admiration of the present age, will be the object of praise and commendation to those who come after us."{{ref|piusx02}} But this is to be done without interfering with sacred studies, as Our same predecessor prescribed in these most weighty words: "If you carefully search for the cause of those errors you will find that it lies in the fact that in these days when the natural sciences absorb so much study, the more severe and lofty studies [i.e., theology and related disciplines] have been proportionately neglected--some of them have almost passed into oblivion, some of them are pursued in a half-hearted or superficial way, and, sad to say, now that the splendor of the former estate is dimmed, they have been disfigured by perverse doctrines and monstrous errors."{{ref|piusx03}} We ordain, therefore, that the study of natural sciences in the seminaries be carried out according to this law.
47. With regard to secular studies, let it suffice to recall here what our predecessor [Leo XIII] has admirably said: "Apply yourselves energetically to the study of natural sciences: in which department the things that have been so brilliantly discovered, and so usefully applied, to the admiration of the present age, will be the object of praise and commendation to those who come after us."{{ref|piusx02}} But this is to be done without interfering with sacred studies, as Our same predecessor prescribed in these most weighty words: "If you carefully search for the cause of those errors you will find that it lies in the fact that in these days when the natural sciences absorb so much study, the more severe and lofty studies [i.e., theology and related disciplines] have been proportionately neglected--some of them have almost passed into oblivion, some of them are pursued in a half-hearted or superficial way, and, sad to say, now that the splendor of the former estate is dimmed, they have been disfigured by perverse doctrines and monstrous errors."{{ref|piusx03}} We ordain, therefore, that the study of natural sciences in the seminaries be carried out according to this law.
Line 47: Line 45:
== Pius XII ==
== Pius XII ==
 +
 +
Pius XII was Pope from 1939 to 1958. He was the first to acknowledge the existence of evolutionary biology -- one commentator has suggested that the Church had learned from its persecution of Galileo not to rush into judgement on scientific matters.
 +
 +
Pius XII was a religious conservative who clearly wasn't happy
 +
== John Paul II ==
== John Paul II ==
Line 96: Line 99:
#{{note|fvc02}}[http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.HTM "First Vatican Council 1869-1870"], taken from Norman Tanner, ed., ''Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils'' (Georgetown University Press, Washington DC, 1990).
#{{note|fvc02}}[http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.HTM "First Vatican Council 1869-1870"], taken from Norman Tanner, ed., ''Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils'' (Georgetown University Press, Washington DC, 1990).
#{{note|pix01}}[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX "Pope Pius IX"], Wikipedia, c. 2005.
#{{note|pix01}}[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX "Pope Pius IX"], Wikipedia, c. 2005.
-
#{{note|jp01}}John Paul II, [http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_jp02tc.htm "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"], address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on 22 October 1996.
+
#{{note|leo01}}[http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/leo_xiii/encyclicals/documents/hf_l-xiii_enc_18111893_providentissimus-deus_en.html ''Providentissimus Deus''], "given at St. Peter's, at Rome, the 18th day of November, 1893, the eighteenth year of Our Pontificate: Leo XII."
-
#{{note|jp02}}John Paul II, [http://www.its.caltech.edu/~nmcenter/sci-cp/sci-coyne.html "Our knowledge of God and nature: physics, philosophy and theology"], Letter "To the Reverend George V. Coyne, S.J., Director of the Vatican Observatory", date 1 June 1988, originally published in ''L'Osservatore Romano (Weekly edition in English)'', '''xxi''':46 (1064), 14 November 1988.
+
#{{note|piusx01}}Pius X, [http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/pius_x/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-x_enc_19070908_pascendi-dominici-gregis_en.html "Pascendi Dominici Gregis"] ("On the Doctrine of the Modernists"), 8 September 1907.
#{{note|piusx01}}Pius X, [http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/pius_x/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-x_enc_19070908_pascendi-dominici-gregis_en.html "Pascendi Dominici Gregis"] ("On the Doctrine of the Modernists"), 8 September 1907.
#{{note|piusx02}}The reference in the original was: "Leo XIII, allocution of March 7, 1880."
#{{note|piusx02}}The reference in the original was: "Leo XIII, allocution of March 7, 1880."
#{{note|piusx03}}''ibid.''
#{{note|piusx03}}''ibid.''
 +
#{{note|jp01}}John Paul II, [http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_jp02tc.htm "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"], address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on 22 October 1996.
 +
#{{note|jp02}}John Paul II, [http://www.its.caltech.edu/~nmcenter/sci-cp/sci-coyne.html "Our knowledge of God and nature: physics, philosophy and theology"], Letter "To the Reverend George V. Coyne, S.J., Director of the Vatican Observatory", date 1 June 1988, originally published in ''L'Osservatore Romano (Weekly edition in English)'', '''xxi''':46 (1064), 14 November 1988.
== Sources ==
== Sources ==

Revision as of 22:38, 14 October 2005

science time-capsules