Evolution and the Vatican
From Scienticity
JNShaumeyer (Talk | contribs) |
JNShaumeyer (Talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
Despite appearances that the continual American controversy over evolutionary biology pits Religion against Science, "Religion" in this context is far from monolithic, the anti-evolutionist forces turn out to be a small but influential federation of Protestant fundamentalists, and there is in fact very little conflict between science and mature theology. | Despite appearances that the continual American controversy over evolutionary biology pits Religion against Science, "Religion" in this context is far from monolithic, the anti-evolutionist forces turn out to be a small but influential federation of Protestant fundamentalists, and there is in fact very little conflict between science and mature theology. | ||
| - | Darwin published ''The Origin of Species'' in 1859, during the | + | Darwin published ''The Origin of Species'' in 1859, during the pontificate of Pius IX. The book was included in the 1948 edition of the ''Index Librorum Prohibitorum'' (the "Index of Prohibited Books"{{ref|index}}), but its notoriety was short lived since the Index was officially suppressed in 1966. |
| - | == | + | == Pius IX == |
| - | + | ||
| - | + | ||
| + | Pius IX convened the First Vatican Council, which is famous for its decree of papal infallibility, in 1869. Among the decrees of the Council is a statement concerning scientific research. In an earlier translation{{ref|fvc01}} [c. 1875], it reads | ||
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
| - | + | Let him be anathema ... Who shall say that human sciences ought to be pursued in such a spirit of freedom that one may be allowed to hold as true their assertions, even when opposed to revealed doctrine. | |
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
| - | + | In a more modern translation{{ref|fvc02}} [c. 1990] and with surrounding text (the statement above is rendered in paragraph 9): | |
| - | In a | + | |
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
| - | + | 5. Even though faith is above reason, there can never be any real disagreement between faith and reason, since it is the same God who reveals the mysteries and infuses faith, and who has endowed the human mind with the light of reason. | |
| - | <br> | + | <br><br> |
| - | + | 6. God cannot deny himself, nor can truth ever be in opposition to truth. The appearance of this kind of specious contradiction is chiefly due to the fact that either the dogmas of faith are not understood and explained in accordance with the mind of the Church, or unsound views are mistaken for the conclusions of reason. | |
<br>[...]<br> | <br>[...]<br> | ||
| - | + | 9. Hence all faithful Christians are forbidden to defend as the legitimate conclusions of science those opinions which are known to be contrary to the doctrine of faith, particularly if they have been condemned by the Church; and furthermore they are absolutely bound to hold them to be errors which wear the deceptive appearance of truth. | |
| + | <br><br> | ||
| + | 10. Not only can faith and reason never be at odds with one another but they mutually support each other, for on the one hand right reason established the foundations of the faith and, illuminated by its light, develops the science of divine things; on the other hand, faith delivers reason from errors and protects it and furnishes it with knowledge of many kinds. | ||
| + | <br><br> | ||
| + | 11. Hence, so far is the Church from hindering the development of human arts and studies, that in fact she assists and promotes them in many ways. For she is neither ignorant nor contemptuous of the advantages which derive from this source for human life, rather she acknowledges that those things flow from God, the lord of sciences, and, if they are properly used, lead to God by the help of his grace. | ||
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
| + | This presentation makes is clearer that the statement is not so much hostile to science as it is trying to be clear about the boundaries between science and theology; the assertions that reason and faith cannot be in conflict will be echoed in later statements by other pontiffs. | ||
| + | |||
| + | It is true that the First Vatican Council followed the publication of ''The Origin of Species'' by 10 years, but there's really nothing to suggest that the decrees of the council were in direct response to it rather than to the mood of the times, which saw scientific advances on many fronts. Indeed, Pius IX, who saw the end of the Papal States during his pontificate, probably had bigger things on his mind.{{ref|pix01}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
== Leo XIII == | == Leo XIII == | ||
John Paul II, in stating that "truth cannot contradict truth", referred to the encyclical [http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/leo_xiii/encyclicals/documents/hf_l-xiii_enc_18111893_providentissimus-deus_en.html ''Providentissimus Deus''], "given at St. Peter's, at Rome, the 18th day of November, 1893, the eighteenth year of Our Pontificate: Leo XII." That encylical concerned the the study of the Scriptures and did not directly discuss science, scientific truth, and its relationship to theology. | John Paul II, in stating that "truth cannot contradict truth", referred to the encyclical [http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/leo_xiii/encyclicals/documents/hf_l-xiii_enc_18111893_providentissimus-deus_en.html ''Providentissimus Deus''], "given at St. Peter's, at Rome, the 18th day of November, 1893, the eighteenth year of Our Pontificate: Leo XII." That encylical concerned the the study of the Scriptures and did not directly discuss science, scientific truth, and its relationship to theology. | ||
| - | |||
| - | |||
However, | However, | ||
| Line 38: | Line 43: | ||
In his 1907 encyclical "On the Doctrine of the Modernists"{{ref|piusx01}}, Pius X wrote a stern -- and lengthy -- denunciation of "modernists" whose attitudes and teachings he found to be a serious threat to the Church. In that context, his remarks in passing on science seem far from hostile; in fact, by today's standards, they are next to indifferent. | In his 1907 encyclical "On the Doctrine of the Modernists"{{ref|piusx01}}, Pius X wrote a stern -- and lengthy -- denunciation of "modernists" whose attitudes and teachings he found to be a serious threat to the Church. In that context, his remarks in passing on science seem far from hostile; in fact, by today's standards, they are next to indifferent. | ||
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
| - | 47. With regard to secular studies, let it suffice to recall here what our predecessor [Leo XIII] has admirably said: "Apply yourselves energetically to the study of natural sciences: in which department the things that have been so brilliantly discovered, and so usefully applied, to the admiration of the present age, will be the object of praise and commendation to those who come after us."{{ref|piusx02}} But this is to be done without interfering with sacred studies, as Our same predecessor prescribed in these most weighty words: "If you carefully search for the cause of those errors you will find that it lies in the fact that in these days when the natural sciences absorb so much study, the more severe and lofty studies [i.e., theology and related disciplines] have been proportionately neglected--some of them have almost passed into oblivion, some of them are pursued in a half-hearted or superficial way, and, sad to say, now that the splendor of the former estate is dimmed, they have been disfigured by perverse doctrines and monstrous errors."{{ref|piusx03} We ordain, therefore, that the study of natural sciences in the seminaries be carried out according to this law. | + | 47. With regard to secular studies, let it suffice to recall here what our predecessor [Leo XIII] has admirably said: "Apply yourselves energetically to the study of natural sciences: in which department the things that have been so brilliantly discovered, and so usefully applied, to the admiration of the present age, will be the object of praise and commendation to those who come after us."{{ref|piusx02}} But this is to be done without interfering with sacred studies, as Our same predecessor prescribed in these most weighty words: "If you carefully search for the cause of those errors you will find that it lies in the fact that in these days when the natural sciences absorb so much study, the more severe and lofty studies [i.e., theology and related disciplines] have been proportionately neglected--some of them have almost passed into oblivion, some of them are pursued in a half-hearted or superficial way, and, sad to say, now that the splendor of the former estate is dimmed, they have been disfigured by perverse doctrines and monstrous errors."{{ref|piusx03}} We ordain, therefore, that the study of natural sciences in the seminaries be carried out according to this law. |
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
== Pius XII == | == Pius XII == | ||
| + | |||
| + | == John Paul II == | ||
| + | |||
| + | In 1996, Pope John Paul II made a speech to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences, known as "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"{{ref|jp01}}, in which he made his clearest remarks about the relationship between the Roman Catholic Church and modern evolutionary biology. | ||
| + | |||
| + | <blockquote> | ||
| + | Today, almost half a century after the publication of the encyclical [<em>Humani Generis</em>, 1950, by John Paul II's predecessor Pius XII], new knowledge has led to the recognition of the theory of evolution as more than a hypothesis. [...] It is indeed remarkable that this theory has been progressively accepted by researchers, following a series of discoveries in various fields of knowledge. The convergence, neither sought nor fabricated, of the results of work that was conducted independently is in itself a significant argument in favor of this theory. And if, at first sight, there are apparent contradictions, in what direction do we look for their solution? We know, in fact, that truth cannot contradict truth (cf. Leo XIII, encyclical <em>Providentissimus Deus</em>). | ||
| + | </blockquote> | ||
| + | |||
| + | In a 1987 letter to the Director of the Vatican Observatory{{ref|jp02}} on the occasion of a "study week" held at Castelgandolfo in Rome to mark the 300th anniversary of the publication of Newton's ''Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica'', John Paul II made broader statements about the cross-fertilization possible between science and theology, remarks that were far from hostile about science. | ||
| + | <blockquote> | ||
| + | Religion is not founded on science nor is science an extension of religion. Each should possess its own principles, its pattern of procedures, its diversities of interpretation and its own conclusions. Christianity possesses the source of its justification within itself and does not expect science to constitute its primary apologetic. Science must bear witness to its own worth. While each can and should support the other as distinct dimensions of a common human culture, neither ought to assume that it forms a necessary premise for the other. The unprecedented opportunity we have today is for a common interactive relationship in which each discipline retains its integrity and yet is radically open to the discoveries and insights of the other. | ||
| + | <br>[...]<br> | ||
| + | If the cosmologies of the ancient Near Eastern world could be purified and assimilated into the first chapters of Genesis, might contemporary cosmology have something to offer to our reflections upon creation? Does an evolutionary perspective bring any light to bear upon theological anthropology, the meaning of the human person as the ''imago Dei'', the problem of Christology -- and even upon the development of doctrine itself? What if any, are the eschatological implications of contemporary cosmology, especially in light of the vast future of our universe? Can theological method fruitfully appropriate insights from scientific methodology and the philosophy of science? | ||
| + | <br>[...]<br> | ||
| + | Contemporary developments in science challenge theology far more deeply than did the introduction of Aristotle into Western Europe in the 13th century. Yet these developments also offer to theology a potentially important resource. Just as Aristotelian philosophy, through the ministry of such great scholars as St. Thomas Aquinas, ultimately came to shape some of the most profound expressions of theological doctrine, so can we not hope that the sciences of today, along with all forms of human knowing, may invigorate and inform those parts of the theological enterprise that bear on the relation of nature, humanity and God? | ||
| + | </blockquote> | ||
== Benedict XIV == | == Benedict XIV == | ||
| Line 71: | Line 93: | ||
== Notes == | == Notes == | ||
#{{note|index}}[http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/indexlibrorum.html "Modern History Sourcebook: Index librorum prohibitorum, 1557-1966"]. | #{{note|index}}[http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/indexlibrorum.html "Modern History Sourcebook: Index librorum prohibitorum, 1557-1966"]. | ||
| + | #{{note|fvc01}}John William Draper, [http://www.positiveatheism.org/hist/draper12.htm ''History of the Conflict Between Religion and Science''], "Chapter XII, The Impending Crisis" (Kegan Paul, Trench, Thrübner & Co. Ltd., London, 1910). | ||
| + | #{{note|fvc02}}[http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.HTM "First Vatican Council 1869-1870"], taken from Norman Tanner, ed., ''Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils'' (Georgetown University Press, Washington DC, 1990). | ||
| + | #{{note|pix01}}[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX "Pope Pius IX"], Wikipedia, c. 2005. | ||
#{{note|jp01}}John Paul II, [http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_jp02tc.htm "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"], address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on 22 October 1996. | #{{note|jp01}}John Paul II, [http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_jp02tc.htm "Truth Cannot Contradict Truth"], address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on 22 October 1996. | ||
#{{note|jp02}}John Paul II, [http://www.its.caltech.edu/~nmcenter/sci-cp/sci-coyne.html "Our knowledge of God and nature: physics, philosophy and theology"], Letter "To the Reverend George V. Coyne, S.J., Director of the Vatican Observatory", date 1 June 1988, originally published in ''L'Osservatore Romano (Weekly edition in English)'', '''xxi''':46 (1064), 14 November 1988. | #{{note|jp02}}John Paul II, [http://www.its.caltech.edu/~nmcenter/sci-cp/sci-coyne.html "Our knowledge of God and nature: physics, philosophy and theology"], Letter "To the Reverend George V. Coyne, S.J., Director of the Vatican Observatory", date 1 June 1988, originally published in ''L'Osservatore Romano (Weekly edition in English)'', '''xxi''':46 (1064), 14 November 1988. | ||
| Line 79: | Line 104: | ||
== Sources == | == Sources == | ||
*George V. Coyne, [http://clavius.as.arizona.edu/vo/R1024/AReports/FDirec00.html "From the Director"], ''The Vatican Observatory: 2000 Annual Report'', 10 April 2001. | *George V. Coyne, [http://clavius.as.arizona.edu/vo/R1024/AReports/FDirec00.html "From the Director"], ''The Vatican Observatory: 2000 Annual Report'', 10 April 2001. | ||
| + | *James Hannam, [http://www.bede.org.uk/historyessays.htm#index "Looking it up in the Index"], 2000. | ||
*Doug Linder, [http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/vaticanview.html "The Vatican's View of Evolution: The Story of Two Popes"], 2004. | *Doug Linder, [http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/vaticanview.html "The Vatican's View of Evolution: The Story of Two Popes"], 2004. | ||
*Keelin McDonell, [http://slate.msn.com/id/2122506/ "What Catholics Think of Evolution: They don't not believe in it."], ''Slate'', 12 July 2005. | *Keelin McDonell, [http://slate.msn.com/id/2122506/ "What Catholics Think of Evolution: They don't not believe in it."], ''Slate'', 12 July 2005. | ||
