View source
From Scienticity
for
Shipman: Taking Wing
Jump to:
navigation
,
search
{{BNR-table|scienticity=5|readability=5|hermeneutics=5|charisma=4|recommendation=5}} Pat Shipman, ''Taking Wing : Archaeopteryx and the Evolution of Bird Flight''. New York : Simon & Schuster, 1998. 336 pages, illustrated, with maps, bibliographic references, and index. The third nerd book I read this year [2009], for the Science-Book Challenge as well as to gain wisdom, was ''Taking Wing'' by Pat Shipman. It was basically a book about the fossil bird ''Archaeopteryx'' and how this fossil explains the origin of birds and the origin of flight. It was a wonderful and very well written account of all of the research on ''Archaeopteryx''. I read this book to gain some insight on research on various hypotheses concerning flight and I got a deeper understanding of the two major competing hypotheses: a) the trees down, and b) the ground up. ''Archaeopteryx'' can be used as evidence for both. Was it a climber that glided down from trees or a "flapper" that could take off from the ground? The evidence is certainly ambiguous. ''Archaeopteryx'' had well-developed wings and feathers, but most fossils show it lacked a well developed sternum for attachment of flight muscles. It also lacked the ability to do a "wing flip" that allows a bird to not stall as it raises its wings for another "stroke". But it's small hallux suggests that it couldn't perch in a tree like a regular bird either. There didn't seem to be trees in the immediate area where the fossils were found either. And it lacked muscles to perch effectively. But, to make a long story short, we still don't know what it could and couldn't do. It perhaps could've taken off from the ground, which is what I tend to think it did. I can highly recommend this book. It was a very quick read and gave much insight. My only complaint is that it is a bit out of date, as it was published in 1998 and mentions quite a bit of Larry Martin and others who dispute that birds are related to dinosaurs (even though 2 of the 7 ''Archaeopteryx'' fossils were mistakenly identified as the dinosaur ''Compsognathus''). But now that 17 species of unequivocally feathered dinosaurs have been discovered, the vast majority of paleontologists and the general public for that matter, agree that dinos are the ancestors of birds...and as my son Max says, birds are dinosaurs. The fact that Larry Martin '''still''' disputes the dino-bird relationship is astounding. But, I do have my own faults, and so I won't throw stones. Alan Feduccia is quoted in the book as saying "There is no evidence that dinosaurs possessed feathers. Feathers are a uniquely bird characteristic". Well, not so any more. I enjoyed this book even more than Heilmann's ''Origin of Birds''. Now I can't wait to read ''Glorified Dinosaurs'' by Louis Chappe. So many books, so little time! {{Notesby|RTS}} [[Category: Book Notes]][[Category: Top-Rated Books]] [[Category: RTS]]
Template:BNR-table
(
view source
)
Template:Bookbug4
(
view source
)
Template:Bookbug5
(
view source
)
Template:Notesby
(
view source
)
Return to
Shipman: Taking Wing
.
Views
Page
Discussion
View source
History
Personal tools
216.73.216.49
Talk for this IP
Log in
science-book challenge
Main Challenge Page
2013 Challenge
2012 Challenge
2011 Challenge
2010 Challenge
2009 Challenge
2008 Challenge
science-book notes
Book Notes
Contributors' Pages
Top-Rated Books
Submission Form
science time-capsules
Time-Capsule Index
meta topics
Scienticity Home
Wiki Front Page
Wiki Outline
All Categories
Comment Form
Mailing List
New pages
All pages
Recent changes
Random page
Help
sitesupport
Search
Toolbox
What links here
Related changes
Special pages